MeerMago
Free guide
Knowledge base

Reviews and reputation

Unfair Google review? What your practice can do

A negative review does not disappear by itself. Find out when reporting it makes sense, how to follow up and which information to keep out of public replies.

approx. 4 min read

Practice manager making a note behind the reception desk

Your practice cannot remove someone else’s review itself. You can ask Google to assess a possible policy violation. Simply disagreeing with the writer is not enough.

Start with one question: what exactly might be against the rules? That is more useful than immediately writing a long defence or asking everyone to report the review.

An upsetting review is not automatically a policy violation

A low rating can describe a genuine experience. Someone may have waited too long, misunderstood a bill or felt poorly treated. That may seem incomplete or one-sided, but it does not automatically make the review eligible for removal.

Google prohibits fake reviews, threats and certain personal information, among other things. Look at the actual wording and the conditions of the relevant rule. Mentioning a name or expressing criticism is not automatically prohibited. The current categories are in Google’s content policy.

That distinction helps avoid spending time on a report with no clear grounds. It also helps you notice genuine feedback instead of focusing only on the number of stars.

Three situations: when does reporting make sense?

Suppose someone writes that they waited twenty minutes. The practice may feel that important context is missing. The first step is to consider what to do with that feedback, rather than assuming the review must be removed.

Is the account name unfamiliar? That is a reason to look further calmly. Someone may use a different account name or may only have contacted the practice by phone. An unfamiliar name is not proof of a fake review.

Does the review contain a specific threat or personal information about someone else? That is a reason to check the relevant Google rule. Support your report with what is visible, without filling in missing facts yourself.

First save what you want to report

Save the review link, the date and a screenshot of the public text. Briefly record which passage you want assessed and why. Agree who will submit the report and who will check the outcome.

Keep it simple. There is no need to add a patient record to a marketing overview. Do not send clinical correspondence or unedited screenshots from the practice administration. If you are unsure what can be shared, ask the responsible person at the practice to check first.

Report the review and follow the outcome

Report the review from your Google profile. Find the official steps and review management tool in Google’s guidance on reporting inappropriate reviews.

Check that tool to see whether your report is still under review or a decision has been made.

Has Google finished assessing it and found no violation? You can submit a one-time appeal through the review management tool. Removal is not guaranteed.

Keep the report and response together. A colleague will not have to search again, and the team will know which step has already been taken. Set a time to check back rather than refreshing Google all day.

Do not post your side of the case below the review

A public reply is not the place to reveal what is in someone’s records. In a 2025 ruling, a disciplinary tribunal found that a dentist should not have disclosed clinical information in a review response. The patient sharing information did not mean that the dentist could publish additional information.

If you do reply, keep it general and calm. You do not need to establish publicly whether someone is a patient. For more on tone and a suitable next step, see responding to a negative review.

What if the review stays online?

You do not have to fight the same battle every day. Consider what the team can learn and whether direct contact would be appropriate. Get relevant help for a threat or a complicated situation rather than fighting it out in public replies.

Do not suddenly ask only happy people for five-star reviews. Stick to a normal, neutral approach in which people choose what they share.

The aim is for the practice to handle a possible problem carefully. That remains useful even when the outcome of the report is not what you hoped for.

Free Patient Enquiry Bundle

Help more patients choose you on Google.

Download the free Patient Enquiry Bundle: 8 steps, and in 15 minutes you will know where to begin.

Get the free guide